Home Value, Assessed Value & Appraised Value: Untangling Three Different Numbers

Quick Answer

"How much is my home worth?" actually has at least three distinct answers depending on which number you mean—market value, assessed value (for property tax), and appraised value (for lending) frequently diverge, sometimes significantly, and confusing them leads to real misunderstandings about pricing, taxes, and financing.

Market Value

What a willing buyer would actually pay a willing seller in the current market—reflected in your agent's CMA (see our separate CMA vs. appraisal guide) and ultimately determined by what a property actually sells for. This is the number most relevant to pricing a listing or evaluating what to offer.

Assessed Value

The value is used specifically to calculate your property tax bill, governed in California by Prop 13 (see our separate Prop 13/19 guide)—generally based on your original purchase price plus limited annual increases (roughly 2% per year), not current market conditions. For long-held East Bay homes, assessed value is often dramatically lower than current market value, precisely because of this Prop 13 mechanism.

Appraised Value

An independent, licensed professional's valuation, typically ordered by a lender as part of a purchase or refinance transaction (see our CMA vs. appraisal guide for how this can diverge from market activity in a competitive market). This number specifically supports the lender's loan-to-value calculation and isn't directly tied to your tax bill or necessarily identical to the eventual sale price.

Why These Three Numbers Can Look So Different for the Same Home

Consider a longtime Berkeley homeowner: their assessed value might reflect a purchase price from decades ago, growing only modestly each year under Prop 13, while their home's actual current market value has appreciated dramatically given the region's long-term appreciation. Meanwhile, an appraisal ordered today would aim to reflect current market value using recent comparable sales—potentially different again from what the home actually sells for in a competitive multiple-offer situation.

Why This Matters Practically

  • Don't use your assessed value to estimate what your home could sell for—this is one of the most common misunderstandings, and for a long-held home, assessed value can dramatically understate actual market value
  • Don't assume an appraisal and your final sale price will always match—particularly in competitive market conditions, these can diverge (see our appraisal gap discussion in the CMA vs. appraisal guide)
  • When evaluating your home's worth for any purpose—selling, refinancing, or general financial planning—be clear about which of these three numbers is actually relevant to your specific question

A Practical Way to Think About It

  • Want to know what you could sell for? Ask your agent for a genuine CMA based on current comparable sales
  • Want to know your property tax bill? Check your assessed value on your county tax bill, understanding it may be well below market value for a longtime owner
  • Refinancing or your buyer is financing? Understand the appraisal is a specific, independent professional opinion that may or may not exactly match your agent's CMA or your actual accepted offer price

FAQ

Why is my assessed value so much lower than what I think my home is worth?

This is expected and normal for a longtime owner under Prop 13—assessed value grows slowly regardless of actual market appreciation, which is precisely the tax benefit this system provides to long-term owners.

Will my property taxes suddenly jump to match market value if I get an appraisal done?

No—an appraisal for lending or personal purposes doesn't trigger a property tax reassessment; reassessment is specifically tied to ownership transfer events or, in some cases, new construction, not to obtaining an appraisal.

Which number should I use when deciding on a listing price?

Market value, informed by your agent's current CMA based on genuinely comparable recent sales—not your assessed value, which is largely irrelevant to what buyers will actually pay.

Can an appraisal come in higher than what I actually sell for?

Yes—while less common than an appraisal coming in below a competitive sale price, appraisals are independent opinions and can diverge from the actual negotiated sale price in either direction.

Bottom Line

These three numbers answer three genuinely different questions—knowing which one applies to your specific situation prevents real confusion about pricing, taxes, and financing.

Want a clear, current picture of your home's actual market value? Let's put together a genuine CMA for your specific property.

About The Parker George Team

Robert Parker and Josie George lead The Parker George Team , a Berkeley-based real estate team serving Berkeley, Oakland, Kensington, El Cerrito, Piedmont, Alameda, Albany, Emeryville, and Richmond. Robert holds the Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS) designation, and the team has been recognized by America's Best and featured in the San Francisco Business Times. Licensed with the California DRE (Robert #01923837, Josie #01990905), the team is based at 801 Delaware St, Berkeley, CA 94710.

Start Your Journey
|
(510) 388-4154

Check out this article next

Permit Requirements for Home Renovations in Berkeley & Oakland: What Actually Needs One

Permit Requirements for Home Renovations in Berkeley & Oakland: What Actually Needs One

Permit Requirements for Home Renovations in Berkeley & Oakland: What Actually Needs One

Read Article